You wouldn’t need me to tell you how much jewelry has been treasured in our lives. From the heirloom passed down or to your luxury pieces bought or gifted, almost everything speaks more of moments, memories, and milestones than just an accessory. But what happens to those pieces when they no longer fit into your style or you simply must declutter your collection? The best place to get value from your piece is to sell it, and in this case, give the piece of jewelry a new life with another person.
Whether a vintage watch by Cartier, a pre-owned diamond ring, or simply lots of old 14-karat gold chains, determining where to sell your goods can be quite overwhelming. Indeed, so many options might seem tempting, and thus knowing where you’ll get the best value and experience is just as important. Throughout this blog, we go in-depth with the best places to sell used jewelry in your vicinity and online. From how to sell used Cartier jewelry down to the best place to sell used gold and diamonds, we cover it all here.
Why Sell Your Used Jewelry?
First, before getting to where to sell your jewelry, it’s good to know why people choose to part with their pieces. There could be a number of reasons to sell jewelry, including:
Decluttering: We all have those pieces that we no longer wear or that no longer fit our style. Selling them enables you to declutter and make room for new ones that you love.
Financial Gain: Jewelry is usually a big investment. Selling pieces you no longer need can provide a quick source of cash against unexpected expenses or to finance new undertakings.
Emotional Closure: Sometimes, jewelry can hold emotions that you may want to shed. Selling it will help you move on while garnering a financial benefit.
Upgrading: By selling old, outdated jewelry, you can upgrade your collection with items that better fit you or are more valuable.
Where is the Best Place to Sell Used Jewelry?
Where to sell your used jewelry would depend on what you are selling, how fast you want to sell it, and just how much money you are hoping to garner. Here are some of the top options:
-
Local Jewelry Stores
For many sellers of secondhand jewelry, local jewelry shops are the first point of contact. Most local shops will buy gold, silver, diamonds, and branded pieces, so this is a good option if you’re looking to sell your jewelry quickly. They can also have on-site experts who will appraise your items and can offer you cash on the spot.
Pros:
- Quick and easy process.
- Appraisals done in person by experts.
- Immediate pay.
Cons:
- Offers are lower compared to other selling methods.
- Limited to what the store is currently interested in buying.
-
Pawn Shops
Pawn shops can be one of the fastest and easiest options if you are looking forward to an immediate sale of your jewelry, especially if you need cash urgently. However, for this option, be so prepared that the offers will come very low since pawnshops normally look to resell items for profit. This avenue of sale works well for used gold, diamonds, or an everyday piece of jewelry.
Pros:
- Immediate offers in cash.
- There are no delays waiting for a buyer to be found.
Cons:
- Payouts may be lower than some other options.
- Not suitable for Cartier and other high-end brands.
-
Auction Houses
If you have high-end or antique pieces, auction houses could be a great outlet. The auction house deals in resale: from pre-owned jewelry from Cartier to rare diamond pieces. Your item will be professionally appraised, and if it fits their auction theme, it can sell for a high price.
Pros:
- You get highly paid for your item.
- Professional appraisal
- Great for pieces that are rare and luxurious.
Cons:
- The selling process can be slow, waiting for the right auction date.
- Auction fees can be high to take into your profit.
-
Consignment Stores
Consignment stores are another option in which used jewelry may be sold, especially in cases of trendy or designer pieces. In this kind of store, they sell an item on your behalf and take a commission on the sale.
Pros:
- You might get higher prices.
- Your jewelry is showcased to interested buyers.
Cons:
- You get paid only when the item sells.
- The store will take a commission, reducing the total amount that you will make from this sale.
-
Online Marketplaces
Selling jewelry online has opened up an entire world of possibilities. Websites such as eBay and Etsy, not to mention social media, enable you to show your work to the world. You can list items yourself, set the price for them, and communicate directly with buyers.
Pros:
- Access to a global audience.
- You control the price.
Cons:
- It takes time and some effort to handle ads and communicate with buyers.
- Scams and fraud are possible.
Where to Sell Used Jewelry Online?
Selling your jewelry online can provide the best combination of convenience, audience reach, and potential profit. Some of the prime online options are listed below:
-
WP Diamonds
WP Diamonds buys and sells luxury and branded jewelry, including Cartier and Tiffany, among other luxury brands. Their process goes like this: free quote, free shipping, and same-day payment upon receipt.
Pros:
- Trusted for high-end pieces
- Free shipping, fast payment
- Expert appraisals
Cons:
- Prices depend on market conditions.
-
The Real Real
The RealReal is an online luxury consignment service; they handle everything from appraisal and photography to selling your items. It is a great option to sell designer and branded jewelry and even used Cartier jewelry.
Pros:
- Professional handling and photography.
- Large audience of luxury shoppers.
Cons:
- High consignment fees.
- Payment can take some time depending on when your item sells.
-
Worthy
The next very popular option is Worthy, which sells high-value jewelry, including diamonds and gold, and branded pieces. Worthy’s auction style lets you realize very competitive offers from qualified buyers to achieve a fair market price.
Pros:
- Transparent auction process
- Expert evaluations
- High prices for diamonds and luxury pieces
Cons:
- It may take some weeks.
- Seller fees
-
eBay
Perhaps the more well-known online marketplace is eBay. You can sell literally anything on eBay, including jewelry. You set your price, and it allows you to either auction or sell at a fixed price. Great for used gold jewelry, diamonds, and branded pieces like Cartier.
Pros:
- Access to a global market.
- Flexible pricing options.
Cons:
- Listing fees and seller commissions.
- Risk of dealing with non-paying buyers.
-
Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace
If you want to sell used jewelry around you, Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace are some of the best local listings. Through those listings, you can connect with other buyers too, who would also be local.
Pros:
- You don’t need to spend any money on shipment charges, as it all occurs at a local level.
- You won’t need to deal with any listing fee.
Cons:
- It comes along with loads of scamming risk.
- You will be required to handle the entire sale yourself.
Tips for Selling Your Used Jewelry
Selling used jewelry can be quite easier and more profit-gaining if done the right way. Take a look at some of the following tips to enhance your chances:
Get Multiple Appraisals: Before selling, get your jewelry appraised by multiple sources to understand the value of the same.
Clean Your Jewelry: A clean piece of jewelry is more alluring and fetches a better price.
Research Market Prices: Look up similar items online to see what they’re selling for. This will help you set realistic expectations.
Be Honest About Condition: Be upfront about any wear, damage, or missing stones. Honesty builds trust with buyers.
Sell at the Right Time: In case the gold, diamond, or luxury brand is in demand at the time of sale, the best price for your jewelry can be fetched.
Conclusion
Where to sell used jewelry really depends on what you are selling and how comfortable you are with different processes. Whichever one chooses among local jewelry stores, online venues, or auction houses, each option is burdened with its share of advantages and disadvantages. The key to all this is research, knowing the value of your jewelry, and finding the right platform that suits your needs. Follow the above tips and successfully sell your used jewelry, getting the maximum out of each piece.
Be it an exquisite Cartier or your simple, everyday gold and diamond jewelry, the right buyer is indeed out there—it’s just a matter of knowing where to look!
